Skip to main content

Joyce Murray, MP


Must Reads

Setting the Record Straight: Bill C-428 No Longer Exists

Posted on August 15, 2011

By circulating inflammatory emails regarding Private Member’s Bill C-428, the Minister of Human Resources and Skills Development’s office continues to knowingly misinform constituents, increase their anxieties, and fuel resentment toward new Canadians. It is important to set the record straight.

Here are the facts:

1.  Former Liberal MP Ruby Dhalla introduced Private Member’s Bill C-428 to reduce old age security wait times for immigrants from certain countries (to be consistent with existing wait times for immigrants from other countries). This Bill never got beyond First Reading. There was never a single vote on it.

2.  The Bill died on the Order Paper when the 40th Parliament was dissolved and the recent federal election was called.

3.  Bill C-428 and its proposal no longer exist. It will not be coming forward for Second Reading.

4.  Introducing a Private Member’s Bill in an effort to address the concerns of constituents is the right and responsibility of individual Members of Parliament, and these Bills sometimes do not reflect Party policy.

5.   Liberal MPs discussed Ms. Dhalla’s Bill and decided they did not support it.

6.  No Liberal MP will be re-introducing Bill C-428 in the House of Commons.

7.  In light of Conservative misinformation and fear-mongering, the former Liberal Party Leader held two separate public press conferences in 2010 to clarify that the Liberal Party of Canada and Liberal MPs did not support the Bill, and if it should ever come forward for debate, Liberals would vote against it. The Conservatives are well aware of this.

8.  The Liberal MP responsible for Seniors and Pension issues at that time, MP Judy Sgro, proceeded to consult widely with Canadians on an array of retirement security issues, and prepared a Liberal platform of targeted pension improvements – one that did not include the changes being proposed by Ms. Dhalla.

9.   Support payments for genuine refugees have nothing to do with old age security payments for Canadians or for immigrants; this point of comparison is proven false on the Citizenship and Immigration Canada website here.

Please feel free to forward these facts to anyone you know who is receiving misinformation regarding Bill C-428.

Let’s put an end to this myth!

Best regards,

Joyce Murray, MP
Vancouver Quadra

Help spread the word by sharing this with your friends.

Short link:

Email this to your friends.
Sender: Sender:
Recipients: Recipients:

Load from: Gmail · Yahoo! · Hotmail · AOL

Personal Message: Personal Message:

We will never share your email address.

We'd love to hear your opinion. Your comments won't be posted on the website.
Sender: Sender:

We will never share your email address.

Our Open Letter to the Minister of National Defence »

August 14, 2014

Please see below, a letter from myself, Liberal Critic for National Defence and Wayne Easter, [...]

Roundtable on immigration hears about Canada’s broken immigration system »

August 21, 2014

(Vancouver, BC) Joyce Murray, MP for Vancouver Quadra and Hon. Judy Sgro MP for York [...]

Meeting with Canadians about the privacy of their internet activity »

August 22, 2014

(Vancouver, BC) Joyce Murray, MP Vancouver Quadra hosted Scott Andrews the MP for Avalon, Newfoundland [...]

Contact Us

Vancouver Office:
206-2112 West Broadway
Vancouver, BC V6K 2C8
Tel: (604) 664-9220
Fax: (604) 664-9221

Ottawa Office:
Room 450, Confederation Building
House of Commons
Ottawa, ON K1A 0A6
Tel: (613) 992-2430
Fax: (613) 995-0770


Joyce on Flickr